Published on September 17 by Ramona
The term "dominance" in the dog world is highly polarizing and often misunderstood. This confusion stems from various interpretations and misrepresentations of the concept, which can complicate discussions about canine behavior.
Does Dominance Exist in Dogs?
Yes, dominance does exist in dogs. However, the way it is perceived and applied can vary widely among dog professionals and trainers. The misunderstanding largely arises from differing viewpoints and the desire to fit information into specific training philosophies.
The Misinterpretation of Dominance
Many dog trainers and enthusiasts focus more on validating their own methods rather than seeking a comprehensive understanding of dominance from a natural perspective. For example, some may advocate that positive reinforcement alone is sufficient, rejecting the idea of dominance altogether. This approach often leads to cherry-picking information that supports their narrative while ignoring broader truths about canine behavior.
Insights from Dr. Mech’s Research
Dr. David Mech’s work on wolves has been particularly influential but also misunderstood. In his 1970 book, Dr. Mech referred to studies, including those by Rudolph Schenkel in 1947, that observed dominance behaviors in captive wolves. These studies suggested that unrelated wolves in captivity engaged in dominance contests to establish an "alpha" position.
However, Dr. Mech later revised his views based on further research. He found that while dominance contests occur in captive settings, the natural dynamics of wolf packs are quite different. In the wild, wolf packs are typically formed by a pair of breeding wolves—the parents—who lead the pack. The pups follow their parents without the need for dominance contests. The parents do assert dominance, but this is a natural part of their role as leaders and caregivers.
The Nature of Dominance
Dominance is not a one-size-fits-all concept but rather a nuanced behavior that varies by context and individual animals. In both wild and domestic settings, dominance exists but manifests differently. For instance:
Dominance in dogs is a complex and multifaceted concept. It exists in both wild and domestic environments, but its application and implications can differ. Understanding dominance requires a balanced view that considers both natural behaviors and the dynamics of domestic life. Recognizing the different contexts in which dominance occurs helps provide a clearer perspective on canine behavior and improves our approach to training and management.
Discover More Content